Ministers ?dithering? over high speed rail project which will ?shackle country with ?1,700 more debt for every household?

By Suzannah Hills

Last updated at 11:49 AM on 9th January 2012

Ministers have been accused of 'dithering' over the HS2 high-speed London to Birmingham rail project by the former transport secretary who first announced the scheme two-years-ago.

The controversial ?32 billion HS2 route would be the biggest UK rail project in over a century and the 100-mile, 250mph link, will cut the journey time between Britain?s two biggest cities from one hour 24 minutes to just 49 minutes.

But the leader of action groups against the London-Birmingham scheme said it would merely 'shackle the country with an extra ?1,700 debt for every household'.

Plans: Ministers are accused of dragging their feet over the controversial high-speed rail line between London and Birmingham

The Government is expected to give the formal go-ahead to the HS2 route some time this week.

The initial plans for the scheme were first announced nearly two years ago by Labour's transport secretary Lord Adonis and he has now expressed his frustration at the lack of progress on the project.

Lord Adonis said: 'The only thing high speed about the development of HS2 in Britain is the treading of water.

Outspoken: Former Secretary of State for Transport Lord Andrew Adonis

'The valid criticism of the Government is not that it is riding roughshod over Nimbys in the Chilterns.

'Rather, ministers have stalled the project while dithering over straightforward local mitigation issues.

'They make the mistake of believing that opposition to big infrastructure projects diminishes the longer you drag out consultation.

'Delay simply entrenches opposition - including hostility within the Conservative Party which is dogging HS2 - and gives it the belief that 'one last heave' will see off a prevaricating government.'

Lord Adonis went on to urge Prime Minister David Cameron to 'advance HS2 with all deliberate speed and with the full authority of the State'.

The Government had been due to make a decision about HS2 before Christmas but Transport Secretary Justine Greening announced that she would not make an announcement until January.

Even if all proceeds to plan, HS2's first phase, from London to Birmingham, would not be ready before 2026.

And the Y-shaped extension, taking the high-speed line north of Birmingham to north east and north west England, would not be completed until about 2032/33.

Ms Greening faces opposition not only from some local councils and some local residents in areas along the route but also from some Tory MPs.

Chairman of Action Groups Against HS2, Jerry Marshall, said that rather than strengthening Britain's position in the global economy, HS2 'if anything, will do quite the opposite.

Opposition: Stop HS2 protest signs in Wendover, Buckinghamshire

He went on: 'Shackling the country with an extra ?1,700 of debt for every British household at a time of austerity will undermine the recovery and inevitably lead to cuts, not only in other vital rail projects, but in other public services.

'The role high-speed rail can play in our transport infrastructure is one of bringing faster, more-frequent and reliable services that benefit the whole country rather than a single, eye-wateringly expensive project that will actually increase journey times for all but the fortunate few able to afford to use it.'

However, Mr Cameron is firmly behind the plan, and with the Government ruling out a third runway at Heathrow airport, HS2 has become the central plank in its transport policy.

But the project has been mired in controversy, with claims and counter-claims as to its merit.

It has also produced probably more vitriol than any infrastructure scheme for years. Indeed, the House of Commons Transport Committee, in a report on HS2, saw fit to urge both sides to cease name calling.

Those keen on the project say that it is much needed, with a Government-commissioned report by Network Rail last week supporting the pro-HS2 lobby's view that improving existing rail lines will not solve the problem of overcrowding.

Opponents of HS2 have said that the pro-lobby's calculations for the project's benefits are wildly optimistic and that the scheme is merely a 'vanity project'.

?

Source: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2084172/Ministers-dithering-high-speed-rail-project-shackle-country-1-700-debt-household.html?ITO=1490

deion sanders shld 2012 sec football schedule medifast miami heat pro bowl sinead oconnor